Fish It! trading: live trade ads

← Back to the board

Verify your Roblox account

Posting an ad or an offer needs a verified username, because an unverified board fills up with fake ads written under other people's names, and those fakes are how most trade scams start. Verification is free, takes about a minute, and this site never sees your Roblox password.

Post a trade ad

Build your ad from the catalog. The picker holds all 278 documented fish at the values published on this site, grouped by rarity from Common up to the single Forgotten fish, so a starter catch and an endgame Secret sit in the same list. Only fish are listed: rods do not trade directly in Fish It!, and gamepasses carry no published values on this site, so neither is priced here. The how trading works guide covers the Level 20 unlock and the Trading Plaza booths where these swaps happen.

Short note (optional, 140 characters, links are removed):

Post my ad

Live trade ads

My chats

Chats open from an ad: press Chat with poster on any ad that is not yours and the conversation starts on this page. When another player opens a chat on one of your ads, it appears in this list too, with a counter for unread messages. A chat stays open while its ad is live on the board; when the ad expires or leaves the board, the chat closes and any trade is finished inside the game.

From listing to booth: the three moves

Move one: get your name verified. The box further down the page issues a one-off phrase. Drop it into your Roblox profile's About section and run the check; the board reads the profile through Roblox's public pages, spots the phrase, and marks you verified. Since a profile can only be edited by its owner, that settles the account question without your password ever entering the picture. Clear the phrase out afterwards; the verified mark remains in this browser.

Move two: make your pitch. Either put up an ad of your own, fish you have on one side and fish you want on the other, with both sides totalled from the values page and the taker's verdict shown beside them, or go to somebody else's ad and hang an offer on it, which gets weighed against their ask from their side. If the deal needs talking over first, every ad has a chat button that opens a conversation with its owner on this page; your chats are kept in the My chats list under the board.

Move three: shake hands at a booth. Terms settled, find each other in game under your verified names (remember trading unlocks at Level 20), walk up to a Trading Plaza booth, and run through the fish on the screen one by one against the ad before accepting. A listing lives for 7 days and then retires itself, and any offers pinned to it live exactly as long as it does.

Reading a verdict on this board

The coin totals come straight off the Fish It! values page, fish by fish, added up per side. The reading itself follows the WFL calculator bands: sides within a tenth of the bigger total of each other are Fair, a gap stretching to a quarter is a Win one way and a Lose the other, and anything beyond a quarter earns the Big labels. Who the reading favours depends on where you stand: on a listing it is written for the player considering the trade, surrender against receipt, while on an offer it is written for the ad's owner, offer against ask.

Now the caveat, and on this board it is a big one. There is no community value list for Fish It! anywhere, and no source we could find publishes what a fish actually sells for, so every figure here is an estimate the site built itself, ranked along the game's rarity and catch odds ladder and marked Estimate on the values page. Use the verdict to sort fair asks from silly ones, then sanity check a close deal against the Recent Average Price the game itself displays on Trading Plaza listings, because that number comes from real sales. One more blind spot: the totals price the species, not the specimen. A mutated fish, or an unusually heavy one, is worth more than the base figure used here, so when the copy in the booth is special, price the copy.

What the board allows, and what it removes

List fish you really own, and price the deal out of the catalog printed on this page. Three things are never trade goods here: Robux, real world money and accounts; Roblox bans trading them too, so ads offering them are taken down on sight. Deals built on trust are also out. If one player is meant to hand fish over first and simply believe the rest will follow, that is not a trade this board carries, because the whole point of the Trading Plaza booth is that both sides settle together. Keep links out of your notes and offers, and do not use an ad as a billboard for another site or server; promotion dressed as a listing gets cleared in the moderation rounds.

Found something that breaks those rules? The report button on every ad and offer files it into the moderation queue with your reason attached, and the team reads that queue on the same rounds that already cover the suggestion board and the community spaces. What happens next is proportionate: rule-breaking listings come down, repeat offenders and posters whose scam reports stand up to checking are banned from posting, and a ban pulls that name's live ads down as well. One precaution runs the other way: if our community watch has seen a username mentioned in connection with a scam, its first ad may sit in review until a moderator has read it. Treat chat by the same code as the board itself: links are never allowed in a message, and each conversation carries a report button of its own.

Questions anglers ask here

Is browsing really open to anyone?

Completely. You can read every listing, run every filter and check the verdict on any ad without an account of any kind. The ownership check only appears when you want to post an ad or put an offer on one, because then the name behind it has to be provably yours.

Will eggvalues ever hold my catch mid-trade?

No, not for a second. We put the two anglers in touch and price the deal on paper; the fish themselves move directly between you at a Trading Plaza booth, and the site never takes custody of fish, items or money.

What is the point of the phrase in my profile?

It is a signature only you can make. Your Roblox About section cannot be touched by anybody else, so when our check finds the phrase sitting there, we know the ads under your name come from you and not from an impersonator hoping to cash in on a known trader's reputation. It also means we never need your password: we never ask for it, see it or store it.

How long will my listing stay up?

A week, counted from the moment it posts. After seven days it expires on its own. Still holding the fish and still willing to trade? Post the ad again, so the board keeps showing only deals that are genuinely live.

So what is the verdict actually comparing?

Two coin totals, each one the values page figures for that side added together, always remembering that every Fish It! figure here is a community estimate rather than an official price. Within a tenth of the larger total the call is Fair, out to a quarter it is a Win or a Lose, and past that a Big Win or Big Lose. The wording is aimed at the player taking the ad, which makes a Win mean the taker lands more value than they give up.

Can I talk to a poster without leaving the page?

Yes, and it is built for exactly that. Hit Chat with poster on somebody else's ad and the conversation opens here, between the two verified names from the listing. The chat blocks links, keeps a short safety notice pinned at the top, and winds up when the ad leaves the board. Agree everything there if you like; the fish still change hands at the booth.

I reported an ad. What happens now?

It sits in the moderation queue with your reason attached until the team's next round, when the listing is read against the board rules and the poster's history. Anything that breaks the rules is removed, and posters who make a habit of it are banned from posting, with their live ads pulled at the same moment.